Singapore's low tax model creaks

Opinion Wednesday 24/January/2018 15:45 PM
By: Times News Service
Singapore's low tax model creaks

Beneath its modern and glitzy exterior, Singapore is ageing.
For the first time in its short history, the Southeast Asian nation is expected to have as many people aged 65 and older as under 15 this year, a demographic crux that challenges the low-tax economic model that helped transform Singapore from port town to financial hub in a matter of decades.
Top government officials have been signalling the need for higher taxes to support future social spending, and with the country forecasting a primary deficit in 2017 that would be the largest in at least 16 years, changes are expected as soon as the budget on February 19.
The city-state has some of the lowest tax rates in the world, with room to adjust parts without risking its competitiveness, but not even its citizens, who stand to be better supported by welfare changes, welcome higher taxes.
A recent study by the Institute of Policy Studies (IPS) showed Singaporeans would rather the government dip into its national reserves than raise taxes.
But economists say things will have to change in a country which has one of the highest life expectancies and lowest fertility rates in the world and marginal increases to the likes of the goods and services tax this year may only be the start of a longer-term rethink.
"People will recognise this period as a period of shifting sands...when things started making the initial shifts," said Vishnu Varathan, head of economics and strategy for Mizuho Bank in Singapore.
"This is when they would have felt the tremors coming through to shake-up the tax structure a little bit."
The city-state's population of seniors is expected to double by 2030, straining the government's budget for healthcare.
The IPS estimates the ageing trend represents a drag of 1.5 percentage points on Singapore's annual GDP per capita growth from 2011 to 2060.
One of the reasons the tax issue has come to the fore in Singapore is because efforts to boost productivity have been slow to bear fruit.
With restrictions on foreign labour, Singapore has championed investment in automation and artificial intelligence to help gear its economy towards higher-value-added industries with strong productivity growth.
But this transition takes time.
Labour productivity growth was flat around 1-1.5 per cent in the years 2013 through 2016, having been at nearly 10 per cent in 2010. Meanwhile Singapore's tax revenue, as a percentage of economic output, is below the average of other high income countries, World Bank data shows.
As a result, the government is projecting a primary budget deficit of S$5.62 billion ($4.3 billion) in 2017.
If realised, that would be the largest since at least 2001 when changes to the classification of some items were brought in.
Singapore's projected and realised primary budget balance has often varied and in 2016 the deficit was about half of what was projected.
Tax changes are already happening.
An increase in the top rate of income tax from 20 to 22 per cent was announced in the 2015 budget and has already kicked in.
Finance Minister Heng Swee Keat told an IPS forum on Monday that without increased revenue from the country's reserves in recent years, some taxes could have doubled.
Changes to the goods and services tax (GST) - which in FY2016/17 accounted for nearly a quarter of total tax revenues - would further firm up government finances.
Economists are expecting a rise to 8 or 9 per cent from 7 per cent, to be announced at the budget - the first hike in a decade.
And there could be more rises in GST in the years to come.
A fictional account of a budget in 2065, penned by current central bank governor Ravi Menon in 2015, saw the GST rate raised to 14 per cent. Menon said his article did not reflect the views or projections of the Monetary Authority of Singapore.
The finance ministry did not immediately respond to a request for comment on expectations for a rise in taxes.
While tax hikes tend to be unpopular with voters, Singapore's government has until January 2021 to hold its next general election.
Sian Fenner, senior Asia economist at Oxford Economics, said over the next five to seven years there could also be more changes to income taxes, while others have pointed to the possibility of wealth taxes, estate duties, property gains tax or even something more novel such as a sugar tax.
Singapore's three main taxes - corporate, income and GST - are relatively low by international standards, but it has stiff taxes on alcohol, tobacco and motor vehicles.
One tax unlikely to rise is corporate tax, experts say.
At 17 per cent, Singapore's headline corporate tax rate is already slightly above that of its closest rival Hong Kong.
"Singapore will be trying to make sure that whilst it is able to meet its own requirements in terms of fiscal revenue, it is also not killing what has made Singapore such a special place," said Richard Mackender, a tax partner at Deloitte.
Credit ratings agencies have flagged the "structural economic and fiscal costs" related to Singapore's rapidly ageing population, but the three main firms have kept their top Triple-A ranking, in part due to its vast sovereign wealth.
The government has other sources of revenue such as returns on assets managed by its sovereign funds.
It can also dip into its historical reserves, although this is protected by the Constitution and requires Presidential approval.
The government says its overall budget balance - taking into account other sources of revenue - is estimated to be a surplus of S$1.9 billion in 2017.
But the longer term structural challenges remain.
The Institute of Policy Studies projects that Singapore's old-age dependency ratio, having been just under nine elder Singaporeans for every 100 persons of working age persons in 1980, will rise to 91 elder per 100 workers by 2080.
"As expenditure on social needs rise, given the country's demographic trajectory, there is however a recognition that tax revenues will have to rise in tandem," the IPS study said. - Reuters